A proven email strategy you can run in your sleep


Build a newbie's Know/Like/Trust factor with an email automation

In my humble opinion, the ideal digital marketing flow for organizations like yours looks like this:

You have an engaging website with strong Search Engine Optimization

⬇️

People find you on Google as they search for "church/school near me"

⬇️

On your website, you offer something of value in exchange for someone's email

⬇️

When they subscribe, a new subscriber automation kicks off

⬇️

Over a series of days, weeks, or months, you build their know/like/trust factor until they visit you in-person!


This is an extremely practical, proven, and low-maintenance approach to digital marketing. It doesn't make you a slave to the Instagram algorithm. You won't go broke on Facebook ads. You'll always own your email list.

Sound like something you want to try? Assuming you have your SEO sorted out (tips here) and a strong lead magnet (30 ideas for churches/schools), give it a go!

Whether you use Kit, MailChimp, or another email service provider, there should be a way to set up a series of emails to trigger whenever someone subscribes to your email newsletter.

My recommendations for writing your new subscriber automation:

  • Make it 3-4 emails long with a day or two between each one.
  • Here are some topic ideas:
    • Introduction to Pastor/Principal
    • Condensed FAQ
    • Highlight your social media (if active and high-quality)
    • Introduction to a classroom teacher (there are ways to set this up so it's based on the preference someone shared when they subscribed: ex - the parent chose 3rd grade from the dropdown in the email signup so they get sent the 3rd grade teacher's introduction. Email me for help.)
    • Opportunity to sign up for BIC, set up a school tour, or meet with the pastor
    • More information regarding the lead magnet (if applicable)
    • An invitation to a recurring event
  • Keep the emails short & sweet (under 250 words).
  • Focus on ONE topic in each email. Don't info dump.
  • Incorporate video wherever possible.
  • In the last email, make it clear that the person will be subscribed to ongoing communication (a weekly devotion or newsletter).

Remember: this is only worth the effort if you have a website and lead magnet that organically attracts subscribers. If you're not there yet, take some time to work on those foundational pieces.

As always - email me if you need help!

Until next week,

Grace Ungemach

I offer digital marketing education written with ministry in mind. Subscribe to my free, weekly newsletter to learn something new every Friday.

Read more from Grace Ungemach

It can feel yucky to set quantitative goals when your primary goal is to simply love people... I get that! The last thing we want to feel like is a used car salesman, just hustling to hit his quota. A SMART goal is Specific, Measurable, Achievable, Relevant, and Time-bound. Setting SMART goals and remaining true to your mission are not mutually exclusive. For example: Instead of telling your congregation members to invite their friends to Christmas Eve, set a SMART goal along the lines of,...

I was writing a presentation recently and realized something huge... You're not ready for this 👀 As a business account, your follower reach is between 1.5% and 3%. Translation: If your business has 1000 social media followers, 22 of them will see your post. As a personal account, your reach is between 20% and 50%. Think about times when you've posted an Instagram story and scrolled through the number of people who viewed it... Translation: If you have 1000 social media followers, 350 of them...

Here's a content idea for your weekly newsletter: Here's a little extra content for you to plug into the next few weeks of regular communication to your people. Maybe you can add it to a portion of your newsletter or send out a quick mass text for the next few weeks. This content shows people five ways to use your online presence to amplify their word-of-mouth outreach. This is education for your insiders, not your prospects—so make sure you properly filter any communications you send. Pay...