Logo Makeover: St. Mark Ministries | Green Bay & De Pere


A while back...

...I posted in the WELS Intersections Facebook group offering to critique/improve a logo. I had a lot of interest, so THANK YOU if you submitted yours. If this newsletter gets a positive response, I hope to do more in the coming months.

Our subject today is the logo for St. Mark Ministries in De Pere & Green Bay, Wisconsin.

If anyone from St. Mark is reading this, you won't hurt my feelings if you dislike what I come up with. 😉 I thank you for allowing me to do this!

Here's what they currently use:

Some thoughts off the bat:

  • I believe their currently icon represents a map—"X marks the spot"—with the X being represented by the cross. I could be wrong, but that's my initial interpretation. Perhaps it's a Bible? Ripples in a lake? I chose not to ask for clarification because it's important that I go off of my raw first impression—since that's likely the first impression of others as well.
  • This logo would be fairly difficult to print in an all-white or all-black version. Here's an example where you can see the cross is almost lost because of how the logo is built. Technically, even this iteration includes gray.
  • They have a collection of other icons they use for youth & family ministry. Browse them here. Overall, they have a pretty clean, modern feel—quite different from their primary logo.
  • I feel this typeface is a bit too quirky. They do use this logo for both their church and school, so I want to find something versatile but a bit more serious.

My ideas (see my Pinterest inspo board here 💡):

  • St. Mark is physically located on two campuses. They also promote their online campus. Because of this, I don't want the logo to be too De Pere or Green Bay-centric. I'm going to steer away from using local landmarks or symbols.
  • So, if I'm not using a local symbol, what else could I incorporate into the logo that would make it uniquely "St. Mark"?
    • St. Mark himself is often represented by the Lion in scripture and tradition. This also happens to be the school's mascot. Bingo! We can work with that.
  • It would be cool to create something that could very easily be adopted or just slightly tweaked for the school's athletic program. Maybe something that could fit into a shield or crest-like shape.
  • In their welcome video, the lead pastor underscores that it doesn't matter where you are on your walk with Jesus—you're welcome at St. Mark if you're at the one-day or 70-year mile-marker. If we use the lion, I don't want it to scare people away or feel too "insider baseball." It has to be subtle. I don't want newbies thinking, "Why is that church's logo a lion?" Perhaps a lion's mane pattern?

The result:

I dropped the saturation on their existing colors and brought in a few neutrals and a charcoal gray (instead of black). The result is a more sophisticated, mature, regal palette.

I found a more polished, modern font (Adobe Clean Bold) and paired it with an all-caps subhead font (Adobe Clean UX Bold):

Put it all together:

Do you think I accomplished my goals?

If I gave this a bit more time, I would build it out with multiple iterations on this primary logo, a cool brand pattern, and maybe some sub-icons to represent their values or ministries. Perhaps I'd create a more saturated version for the school with a more literal lion illustration. Perhaps I'd make a neat animation for them to use at the beginning of their YouTube videos.


Thanks for reading! Until next week,

Grace Ungemach

I offer digital marketing education written with ministry in mind. Subscribe to my free, weekly newsletter to learn something new every Friday.

Read more from Grace Ungemach

You all have really loved my Pinterest boards for business cards & brochures... It's time to look at a whole bunch of merch inspo. 😍 You'll see a lot of wedding favors and wedding party gifts; these are just there to show you just how many products can be customized these days and get your gears turning. Browse my board The content of this board could be used in a variety of ways: Items on sale to your people so they can "rep" their church or school New visitor gifts Small disposable or...

It's been a while since we went FULL nerd-mode. Today's the day, ladies & gentlemen. 🤓 This past week, I was asked a question: "Can you make the livestream button only show up on Sunday mornings?" Well, of course! Do I have any idea how to do that? No! Will I figure it out? Yes! And I did! Why do this? We wanted to make a BIG RED BUTTON show up on the homepage of the church's website so that a few older, home-bound members could easily find the link. BUT—we didn't really want this slightly...

Sending out Easter postcards? Here are a few ways to squeeze the most possible value out of that pretty significant investment. 1) Incentivize a QR code scan Ideally, try to get the recipient to interact with the mailer. Choose an action that's likely to pique your particular community's interest. Here are a few ideas: Scan for 7 SMS devotions leading up to Easter morning Scan to see the breakfast menu Scan for an email reminder on Good Friday RSVP for the egg hunt on Facebook Scan for Holy...