The best way to set up your website's menu


Why is the organization of your main menu important?

First and foremost, you want the user on the other side of the screen to have a positive experience on your site. This includes being able to find what they're looking for easily. Additionally, it boosts your SEO to have a logical, clean, simple navigation.

Scroll to the end to see my favorite menu layout and the one I recommend to most of my clients.


1) As a general rule of thumb, stick to 5 (or fewer) main menu items.

Keep your main menu short, sweet, and generic. Then, when you need to add something, add dropdown items underneath those broad categories rather than new menu items. This eliminates visual clutter and makes it easier for users to make their first click.

2) Longer pages are better than additional pages.

For example, instead of a page for each classroom in your school, group all your classrooms onto one page with a clickable navigation near the top that will scroll the user down to the selected classroom.

This will not only boost your SEO, but also make information easier to find by removing visual clutter.

3) Don't get too creative with the actual words you use for menu items.

I see some people getting creative with their menu items and theming them around their values or mission statement.

I'm looking at you: Gather, Grow, Go. 👀

Although this feels like good branding, unless someone has already been educated on these terms, this is only going to cause confusion. Although it may feel bland, stick with menu items that people expect and understand how to navigate.

4) Consider using icons instead of words for certain menu items to save space.

Use a magnifying glass instead of "Search". Use social media icons instead of "Facebook" and "YouTube" (more on that next week 🤫). Consider using a heart or coin instead of "Donate."

5) Make your logo clickable to your home page.

People expect this to be functional and it's an easy upgrade to make.


My very favorite way to lay out a menu:

HOME (Self-explanatory)

ABOUT US

Anything about YOU: Meet the pastor/staff, church history, what we believe, mission & values, accreditation, etc.

SERVING YOU

Anything done for THE READER: Worship, education, events, children's ministry, after school care, extracurriculars, etc.

CONTACT (Self-explanatory)

GIVE (if church) // BOOK A TOUR (if school)

Feel free to play with the verbiage slightly to make it your own. But, in general, shoot for a menu item focused on you 🫵, a menu item focused on them 👨‍👩‍👧, as well as the usual home/contact/give items.


Have questions about how your site is laid out? Shoot me a message and we'll look at it together.

Until next week,

Grace Ungemach

I offer digital marketing education written with ministry in mind. Subscribe to my free, weekly newsletter to learn something new every Friday.

Read more from Grace Ungemach

A while back... ...I posted in the WELS Intersections Facebook group offering to critique/improve a logo. I had a lot of interest, so THANK YOU if you submitted yours. If this newsletter gets a positive response, I hope to do more in the coming months. Our subject today is the logo for St. Mark Ministries in De Pere & Green Bay, Wisconsin. If anyone from St. Mark is reading this, you won't hurt my feelings if you dislike what I come up with. 😉 I thank you for allowing me to do this! Here's...

The Church Marketing Playbook: Throwing Wide Open Your Digital Front Doors It was an absolute pleasure to present at Wisconsin Lutheran Seminary this week. Here's the description shared with attendees: The Church Marketing Playbook: Throwing Wide Open Your Digital Front Doors Within the next 4 to 40 months, you can confidently say you'll be carving out Saturday mornings for church workdays, receiving emails titled, "Re: New lawnmower" from your grounds elder, and vacuuming cheerios off the...

I'm working on materials for my presentation at Mission & Ministry next week... While I'm at it, I thought I'd share this resource with you. Have you ever sat down to formulate a plan for promoting an upcoming event and thought... "Where should I begin?" Then... you get overwhelmed by all of your options, procrastinate, and end up throwing $30 at Facebook 6 days out from the event? This timeline & checklist was written to infuse a little more intention and strategy into that process. You'll...